Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Trade Discussions - Why the Secrecy?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Mess
    replied
    LBF wrote: View Post
    it's because of things like bleacher report where it's the fans writing and youy get people saying oh this isn't a good trade for this team because this guy's always injured and this guys way better, this guy will end up being benched and bought out because he doesn't want to play hear.

    you get people inside the organizatioin reading these and then the gm ends up changing his mind and the trade never happens.
    I sincerely hope no GM changes his mind based on what gets said on an internet forum.

    Leave a comment:


  • LBF
    replied
    it's because of things like bleacher report where it's the fans writing and youy get people saying oh this isn't a good trade for this team because this guy's always injured and this guys way better, this guy will end up being benched and bought out because he doesn't want to play hear.

    you get people inside the organizatioin reading these and then the gm ends up changing his mind and the trade never happens.

    the reason people like doug smith or adrien wosniewski(w/e his name is) don't say this is a bad trade is because they get payed to writer stuff and if you start writing negative crap about trades and stuff thye can get in shit.

    so, it's better if the organization just doesn't admit to anything although soemone will evewntually end up spilling the beans.

    Leave a comment:


  • Buddahfan
    replied
    tbihis wrote: View Post
    Can anybody shed light on why teams need to be super secretive on trade discussions that theyre involved in?
    I would tell you but it is a secret

    Leave a comment:


  • MaGIX
    replied
    you can't bluff when you show your hand
    quit asking bc to show us his cards

    Leave a comment:


  • TheGloveinRapsUniform
    replied
    lets play poker!

    Leave a comment:


  • Apollo
    replied
    Doc Naismith wrote: View Post
    I think you pretty much just answered your own question. Its all about "the leverage" and being as discrete as possible.
    Exactly. It`s one big game of poker. Anyone here show other players their cards in Hold'em before the chips are down? Call me, let's have a game.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bendit
    replied
    Sometimes potential (?) trades are in fact purposely leaked to receive counter offers/calls from other teams.... and as trial balloons to gauge value.

    Leave a comment:


  • octothorp
    replied
    It's also about managing fan expectations. By far the majority of trades that are discussed never come to fruition. If you tell the fans every trade you discuss, all you're going to get are angry fans (and media pundits) who feel that many of the uncompleted trades are a failure on the part of the GM.

    Leave a comment:


  • TheGloveinRapsUniform
    replied
    Katman wrote: View Post
    Maybe because it's the classy thing to do. So the parties mentioned in theses trades, most of which don't happen, don't find out. I don't think it's unreasonable for a player to find out about a trade before the public.
    player's perspective...thats right...

    Leave a comment:


  • Katman
    replied
    Maybe because it's the classy thing to do. So the parties mentioned in theses trades, most of which don't happen, don't find out. I don't think it's unreasonable for a player to find out about a trade before the public.

    Leave a comment:


  • TheGloveinRapsUniform
    replied
    hahaha. i said that was the "logical" response. but i think there maybe more to it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Doc
    replied
    I think you pretty much just answered your own question. Its all about "the leverage" and being as discrete as possible.

    Leave a comment:


  • TheGloveinRapsUniform
    started a topic Trade Discussions - Why the Secrecy?

    Trade Discussions - Why the Secrecy?

    Can anybody shed light on why teams need to be super secretive on trade discussions that theyre involved in?

    I mean the logical thing is probably because they dont want other teams to jump in and steal the transaction from them, but do NBA teams really do this? If they hear a trade discussion going on, are they like "hey, lets think of something better to offer the other team and try to beat that other team out of that trade" i mean it kinda sounds pathetic, coz youd think teams are actually looking at their rosters and trying to go into trade discussions to better their team, not to steal another team's trade or spite another team.

    I think its funny how sometimes they deny that their is a potential deal going down and 2 hours later they tell the media that they just agreed to a trade.

    When a reporter says "according to my sources", does that mean its stolen information?
Working...
X