Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rating raptor players

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Rating raptor players


  • #2
    Don't mean to be a d!ck but Josh Smith has never been an all-star.

    Comment


    • #3
      your ratings suck.

      Bargnani: 1`-2
      AJ: 6-7
      Calderon 5 -6
      Barbosa 6
      Demar derozan 7 - 8(in the future)
      JJ: 6 - 7
      Bayless 6 -7(future)
      Sonny 4 - 5
      Alexis Ajinca 5 -6(if he adds some muscle)
      Wright: 4 -5
      Joey: 4-5
      Reggie 4- 5
      Kleiza too soon to tell
      Ed 7 - 8(future)

      Comment


      • #4
        Bargnani: 5 - 6
        Amir Johnson: 5
        Calderon: 5
        Barbosa: 5
        DeRozan: 6
        James Johnson: 4
        Bayless: 4
        Weems: 3
        Ed Davis: 5
        Kleiza: 3
        Reggie: 3
        Wright: 2
        Dorsey: 2
        Ajinca: 1

        As of right now we have one player who is capable of starting most games on an average team. Pretty sad.

        Comment


        • #5
          Raptors_ wrote: View Post
          your ratings suck.

          Bargnani: 1`-2
          AJ: 6-7
          Calderon 5 -6
          Barbosa 6
          Demar derozan 7 - 8(in the future)
          JJ: 6 - 7
          Bayless 6 -7(future)
          Sonny 4 - 5
          Alexis Ajinca 5 -6(if he adds some muscle)
          Wright: 4 -5
          Joey: 4-5
          Reggie 4- 5
          Kleiza too soon to tell
          Ed 7 - 8(future)
          Thanks god your not the raptors talent evaluator. You would be laughed at histerically. I can imagine your recommendations to the gm.. well I have conculded that Ed Davis is 4 times better than Bargnani while Ajinca is 3 times better therefore i recommend you trade Bargnani. GM response = Quick glance at recommendation + quick glance up at you + laugh histerically = your fired.

          Comment


          • #6
            Raptors_ wrote: View Post
            your ratings suck.

            Bargnani: 1`-2
            AJ: 6-7
            Calderon 5 -6
            Barbosa 6
            Demar derozan 7 - 8(in the future)
            JJ: 6 - 7
            Bayless 6 -7(future)
            Sonny 4 - 5
            Alexis Ajinca 5 -6(if he adds some muscle)
            Wright: 4 -5
            Joey: 4-5
            Reggie 4- 5
            Kleiza too soon to tell
            Ed 7 - 8(future)
            the whole point was to rate them right now, not in the future. Personally, I can't see the future. Yeah, DeMar or ed might be 8's some day. Maybe, maybe not: but the fact they are 5's right now helps explain why the Raptors are a 20 win team.

            Also, rating Bargnani as deserving to be in the D-League or the end of the bench suggests you might not be very good at evaluating NBA talent.
            Last edited by malefax; Sun Mar 27, 2011, 06:58 PM.

            Comment


            • #7
              Matt52 wrote: View Post
              Don't mean to be a d!ck but Josh Smith has never been an all-star.
              Fair enough. I still think he's an 8, tho. He's really, really good, IMHO. Maybe that makes him a 7, since apparently I'm a fan and I think he should be an all-star.

              Macc: I don't think we can say DeRozan is an average starter. He's such a bad defender right now, and his offense is just ok. All the stats suggest he is not helping the team much atm.
              Last edited by malefax; Sun Mar 27, 2011, 07:02 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                The better Ranking would be against the other players in the NBA in their position.

                Jose : Among the PG, he is around 8 ( There are 8 better PGs in the league)
                DD: Among Shooting Guards around 12 ( There are 12 better shooting guards in the league)
                Amir: 20 Among the PFs ( There are 20 better PFs in the league than Amir)
                James Johnso: 20 among SFs ( There are 20 better SFs in this league)
                AB: 5 Among centers ( There are only 5 better centers in this league).

                Comment


                • #9
                  malefax wrote: View Post
                  Fair enough. I still think he's an 8, tho. He's really, really good, IMHO. Maybe that makes him a 7, since apparently I'm a fan and I think he should be an all-star.

                  Macc: I don't think we can say DeRozan is an average starter. He's such a bad defender right now, and his offense is just ok. All the stats suggest he is not helping the team much atm.
                  Yeah but his offence alone is enough for him to be a starter on an average team (Portland, New Orleans). His defence + some areas of offence (ball-handling, 3pt shot) is why he's not a 7. I'd say he's more of a 5.5 to be honest.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    DunkinDerozan wrote: View Post
                    Thanks god your not the raptors talent evaluator. You would be laughed at histerically. I can imagine your recommendations to the gm.. well I have conculded that Ed Davis is 4 times better than Bargnani while Ajinca is 3 times better therefore i recommend you trade Bargnani. GM response = Quick glance at recommendation + quick glance up at you + laugh histerically = your fired.
                    I'd rather have a guy who's skinny as a twig but actually tries on defence and gets a few boards and blocks rather than a retarded italian bigman who can barley defend or grab a single rebound a game.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      malefax wrote: View Post
                      the whole point was to rate them right now, not in the future. Personally, I can't see the future. Yeah, DeMar or ed might be 8's some day. Maybe, maybe not: but the fact they are 5's right now helps explain why the Raptors are a 20 win team.

                      Also, rating Bargnani as deserving to be in the D-League or the end of the bench suggests you might not be very good at evaluating NBA talent.
                      ok nevermind then

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Raptor4Ever wrote: View Post
                        AB: 5 Among centers ( There are only 5 better centers in this league).
                        now thats a joke.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          GarbageTime wrote: View Post
                          now thats a joke.
                          LOL ya. More like Last

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I'll play along...

                            Amir Johnson: 6
                            Calderon: 6
                            Bargnani: 5 (He's an 8 on offense and a 2 on defense, so that equals a 5)
                            Barbosa: 5
                            DeRozan: 5
                            Ed Davis: 5
                            Reggie: 4
                            James Johnson: 4
                            Bayless: 3
                            Weems: 3
                            Kleiza: 3
                            Dorsey: 2
                            Wright: 2
                            Ajinca: 2

                            That's an average rating of 3.9, and the starting unit averages 5.2, which pretty much explains the 20 win total.
                            Read my blog, The Picket Fence. Guaranteed to make you think or your money back!
                            Follow me on Twitter.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Calderon: 6
                              Ed Davis: 6
                              Amir Johnson: 5
                              Bargnani: 5
                              Barbosa: 5
                              DeRozan: 5
                              Reggie: 4
                              James Johnson: 4
                              Bayless: 4
                              Kleiza: 3
                              Wright: 3
                              Weems: 2
                              Dorsey: 2
                              Ajinca: 2

                              A lot of fives and fours...

                              But if it was done on potential, it would be much better!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X