Matt52 wrote:
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Bill Simmons Sums Up our Offseason
Collapse
X
-
What is most refreshing about Simmons' writing is that he writes from the viewpoint of a fan, a Celtics fan with Clippers season tickets. It's easy for him to marginalize the Raptors and Canada for that matter because his loyalty is to all things Boston and the fact that his employer, ESPN is blocked from broadcasting into the Canadian market.
Comment
-
I have no problem with Simmons, and greatly enjoyed reading his basketball bible. He does write from a more fan perspective than journalist perspective. However, he regularly misquotes the details of signings and contracts, making them sound worse they than often are. I imagine he does this for two reasons, 1) He likes baiting people (not just raps fans) and 2) Because a "horrible deal" is more likely to get people to read than "pretty average deal".
Simmons, and Grantland can be a good source of entertainment and information, but when it comes to "breaking news" Simmons can't be relied upon to be accurate."They're going to have to rename the whole conference after us: Toronto Raptors 2014-2015 Northern Conference Champions" ~ ezzbee Dec. 2014
"I guess I got a little carried away there" ~ ezzbee Apr. 2015
"We only have one rule on this team. What is that rule? E.L.E. That's right's, E.L.E, and what does E.L.E. stand for? EVERYBODY LOVE EVERYBODY. Right there up on the wall, because this isn't just a basketball team, this is a lifestyle. ~ Jackie Moon
Comment
-
I'm very surprised at the negativity towards simmons here. Even the guys saying he's good for "entertainment." Come on, he really knows his shit, especially about basketball. I'd go so far to say that he knows more about basketball than anybody on raptors republic. He's entertaining, yes. But his popularity is based as much on this depth of sports knowledge as it is on this entertaining style of writing.
The point that he is not a "journalist" is irrelevant for the purposes of discussing his take on the raptors offseason, and I don't know why it was even brought up.
He does make jokes about relocation from time to time, but if you're taking that personally, it's time to grow up a bit. Those jokes are part of being a sad-sack franchise that's perpetually in the lottery. If anything, you should be upset with colangelo for putting us in position to be the butt of these jokes.
Comment
-
Letter N wrote: View PostSome yuks are blown at every team though, that's like getting mad at an insult comic
and the entertaining time was mostly those 2 years we made the playoffs, especially when garbo and parker first came
and matt fair enough, I am a big Simmons fan but I also don't think he wrote anything ridiculous here, just the facts mixed with comedy.
But then he goes and spoils it with that last line. That is the type of shit that bothers me about him. Again, I'm willing to admit I am a sensitive, panzy, touchy, thin-skinned Raptor fan but the relocation stuff is ridiculously ignorant. We will likely find 15 franchises - some of which are playoff teams - that are more likely to be moved when looking at fan support and profitability.
Comment
-
Matt52 wrote: View PostI actually think the article is a very funny and accurate description of the off season.
But then he goes and spoils it with that last line. That is the type of shit that bothers me about him. Again, I'm willing to admit I am a sensitive, panzy, touchy, thin-skinned Raptor fan but the relocation stuff is ridiculously ignorant. We will likely find 15 franchises - some of which are playoff teams - that are more likely to be moved when looking at fan support and profitability.
Comment
-
Matt52 wrote: View Post3) I am tired of his relocation/digs against Raptors/Toronto - I find it ignorant given how profitable and strong the fan base is and akin to picking on the fat kid with the stutter in grade school because the majority are ignorant enough to find it hilarious.
I think many Toronto fans have chips on their shoulders (myself included) because we're often the lone Canadian city (except NHL of course) to play in the American professional leagues. Sometimes I wonder if Simmons is doing this only to infuriate the fans of Toronto.
And I think the last thing the NBA wants is to contract the league from an international market. They're trying to grow the brand globally and Toronto shipping town would be a huge blow Stern and co. Best thing to do is just laugh when Simmons talks bs.Walking like I'm already there.
Comment
-
10 000 Hours wrote: View PostYes, it can be ignorant, but as you said, the Raptors are not leaving Toronto, so why care so much what one person says? I dislike hearing what he says sometimes, but he is who he is.
I think many Toronto fans have chips on their shoulders (myself included) because we're often the lone Canadian city (except NHL of course) to play in the American professional leagues. Sometimes I wonder if Simmons is doing this only to infuriate the fans of Toronto.
And I think the last thing the NBA wants is to contract the league from an international market. They're trying to grow the brand globally and Toronto shipping town would be a huge blow Stern and co. Best thing to do is just laugh when Simmons talks bs.
Comment
-
-
He's called "The Sports Guy" for a reason. He loves sports, he's incredibly enthusiastic about the NBA and while he does know a ton, he doesn't know everything (which doesn't stop him from acting like he does sometimes). Not a journalist, he was basically a blogger before that term existed and put a lot of effort in to make it to where he is today.
His writing is entertaining and he has some funny stuff, but that Toronto relocation line was simply just a throwaway joke. There's no notion to perpetuate about the Raptors moving, yes you are thin-skinned and sensitive.
He had Chad Ford on his podcast a few weeks ago, they were chatting about JV and he was drinking the kool aid and getting hyped. I was excited that a notable American sports media outlet was talking about the Raptors, but that excitement ended once he made up some ridiculous trades where the Raptors ended up with Pau Gasol and Steve Nash (He'd fit right in on the Trade forum).
He's a fan, not a journalist, and for all the NBA knowledge he has, sometimes he sounds like he doesn't have a clue.Two beer away from being two beers away.
Comment
-
Simmons is a fun read. I like his stuff. But not a journalist.
About Landry Fields, though:
you guys know that if Landry Fields signed ANY offer sheet with Toronto, he couldn't be used in a sign and trade, right? So Toronto did not have to give him a big contract in order to sabotage the Knicks. Even if it was a contract that the Knicks were sure to match, it would serve the purpose.
Therefore, the fact that the contract was made a poison pill means Colangelo ACTUALLY WANTED TO SIGN FIELDS. It was not necessary to offer Fields that much money unless Colangelo did not want the Knicks to match. Therefore, the idea that we are 'stuck' with Fields is, from Colabgelo's perspective, false. He wanted Fields at that price regardless of whether Nash was coming.
Therefore Simmons, unsurprisingly, doesn't know what the f*ck he is talking about and is totally misreading the situation.
Comment
Comment